An advertisement recently popped up on my Facebook feed featuring a celebrity’s wife enthusiastically praising lactic acid bacteria imported from Japan. In the sponsored post, she passionately advocated the virtues of lactic acid bacteria, claiming that both she and her husband had their nasal allergy symptoms completely cured by them. Today, let us explore the question: “Do commercial lactic acid bacteria and probiotic products really have miraculous effects in treating nasal allergies?”

To state the conclusion upfront: because physiological applications of bacteria such as lactic acid bacteria or probiotics remain in the early stages of research, and various manufacturers continuously introduce newly developed strains, there is currently no conclusive medical evidence to substantiate these claims. Consumers taking newly marketed probiotic formulations today are essentially participating in the largest human guinea-pig trial in history; the only caveat is that determining whether such trials cause harm to the human body involves subtle, long-term outcomes that are difficult to isolate.

For example, the lactic acid bacteria imported from Japan that the celebrity’s wife lauded was developed by Japanese pharmaceutical manufacturers tailored to the gut microbiomes of the local Japanese population. Yet dietary habits differ considerably between our country (the ROC) and Japan; are bacterial strains formulated for the Japanese constitution genuinely appropriate for people in Taiwan? In all likelihood, experiencing no negative symptoms is largely a matter of luck. In plain terms: “if nothing went wrong after consuming it, you were simply fortunate.” If it coincidentally suppressed your nasal allergies without producing long-term side effects, consider it a stroke of pure fortune.

Dr. Tsung-Chieh Yao, an attending physician at the Pediatric Allergy and Asthma Center of Linkou Chang Gung Memorial Hospital, previously pointed out in his article Health Foods, Alternative Therapies, and Allergic Diseases: Starting with Probiotics that a long-term Dutch medical cohort study found that children given Lactobacillus rhamnosus GG (LGG) did see a one-third reduction in atopic dermatitis by age seven; however, their risk of developing asthma tripled, and their risk of allergic rhinitis doubled.

In reality, once a single bacterial strain is ingested long-term, it can become the dominant species in your microbiome, potentially triggering numerous unpredictable effects. In the absence of medical supervision, diagnostic monitoring, and dosage adjustments by a physician, consuming a probiotic heavily based purely on intuition (or marketing campaigns) is fundamentally no different from trying an unverified folk remedy.

In his conclusion, Dr. Yao specifically cautioned the public not to assume probiotics are entirely risk-free while ignoring potential hazards, including disruptions to carbohydrate and lipid metabolism, as well as immune dysregulation. In particular, pregnant women and young children contemplating long-term use must understand these potential risks beforehand.

He further noted that several cases have emerged globally in recent years where probiotic consumption led to sepsis and even death. In addition, excessive use of probiotics risks creating a breeding ground for “superbugs.” Because many lactic acid bacteria carry multi-drug resistance against antibiotics, coexisting and interacting with pathogenic bacteria may allow them to transfer antibiotic-resistance genes, potentially rendering pathogens resistant to treatment and leaving infections untreatable.

✦ Independent Journalism · Reader Support ✦

Support Independent Perspectives & In-Depth Insights

Every thoughtful analysis and candid critique comes from our dedication to truth and quality. We choose not to follow sensational algorithms or clickbait headlines.

Sustaining independent research requires reader support. Make a one-time or monthly contribution, securely processed by Google.

Payments secured by Google · Manage or cancel anytime in your Google Account