Last year, TSMC earned 350 billion NTD in profit and paid 26 billion in taxes; Foxconn earned 140 billion in profit and paid 18 billion in taxes. Together, the two corporations accounted for more than 40% of the self-assessed corporate income tax collected by the Northern National Taxation Bureau. As for myself, I prefer to keep a low profile—plus my corporate income tax is filed with the Southern National Taxation Bureau—so I won’t compare raw earnings here. But I can publicly state that between Terry Gou, Morris Chang, and myself, our combined enterprises account for 15% of all corporate income tax self-assessed nationwide across the Republic of China.
So I really must have a word with Old Gou. For corporate taxpayers of our caliber, merely knowing how to pay taxes is practically embarrassing. If money is to be used efficiently, it must be kept far away from politicians and government bureaucracy. My friends know this very well—people like Bill Gates, Warren Buffett, and Morris Chang. We must find ways to deliver capital directly into the hands of grassroots citizens.
Take an example from right here on the island of Taiwan: when the Kaohsiung gas explosions occurred, Foxconn’s Chairman Terry Gou donated 10 million NTD to the Kaohsiung City Government’s disaster relief account. Chairman Morris Chang of TSMC led by donating 0 NTD—not a single cent under the corporate or personal name, giving zero face to green-camp heavyweight Mayor Chen Chu, visibly demonstrating complete lack of faith in “Flower Mom” (Chen Chu).
And the result? Eight months later, only 40% of the 4.6 billion NTD in charitable relief donations had actually been disbursed; after a year, only 60%. Later, 800 million remained sitting idle in the city treasury, and Chen Chu ended up in litigation over controversies regarding the untraceable whereabouts of 3 billion NTD in spent disaster funds.
TSMC, on the other hand, immediately mobilized direct physical assistance to disaster victims following the Kaohsiung explosions. Their relief reconstruction projects were completely finished before National Day (the explosions happened in August; National Day is in October). In total, TSMC repaired 659 buildings for 361 affected households, erected 4,858 meters of security fencing, built 5 temporary bridges, and paved 4,576 meters of temporary roads (by statutory definition, any road not paved by the city council is deemed temporary, though the paving quality should frankly make Mayor Chen Chu blush). With more than 4,000 cumulative worker dispatches, their astounding efficiency deeply moved local residents, who printed red welcome banners at their own expense to line the streets and applaud TSMC’s departing crews—news footage you can still find online today.
Even putting aside unique disasters like the gas explosion, let’s talk about everyday routines. Taxpayers of our caliber should really compare the operational efficiency of our philanthropic foundations.
I will not dwell on how extraordinarily efficient the foundations of my friends Bill Gates and Warren Buffett are. Looking at Morris Chang’s TSMC Education and Culture Foundation, setting aside the solid work of the TSMC Literature Award in nurturing creative talent, look at their donation of the Children’s Art Education Center at the Taipei Fine Arts Museum: established in 2013, it was built and operational by 2014. Because grassroots arts education offers no financial spoils, politicians from neither the Pan-Blue nor Pan-Green camp took any interest in interfering—so that money, in my view, was exceptionally well spent.
Now look at Terry Gou’s YongLin Foundation. Ten years ago, he pledged 10 billion NTD to the public National Taiwan University Hospital to build a proton therapy center for cancer research and treatment. Purchasing radioactive equipment and constructing medical facilities all require government permits and regulatory licenses. Once politicians from both sides smelled potential leverage and profit… well, I won’t elaborate further. In short, ground was only finally broken 10 years later (June of this year).
So I say to you, Old Gou: for taxpayers of our status, if we simply hand over tax money to the government to let them spend it on “forward-looking” grandiosity, it is hardly efficient. Paving a few tram tracks, constructing mosquito halls, shutting down nuclear plants only to restart them again—that is hardly something to boast about.
By / Wu Kang-wei
Support Independent Perspectives & In-Depth Insights
Every thoughtful analysis and candid critique comes from our dedication to truth and quality. We choose not to follow sensational algorithms or clickbait headlines.
Sustaining independent research requires reader support. Make a one-time or monthly contribution, securely processed by Google.
Payments secured by Google · Manage or cancel anytime in your Google Account




Comments