Late last night, news broke that the National Communications Commission (NCC) chose Friday evening after office hours to dispatch a courier to the Broadcasting Corporation of China (BCC), delivering an official document ordering the immediate shutdown of two beloved stations: “BCC Music Network (FM 96.3 MHz)” and “BCC Formosa Network (FM 105.9 MHz)”. Without prior warning, these stations—which had accompanied the people of Taiwan for decades—were forced by government mandate to cease broadcasting signals starting right at midnight. Hearing these two long-familiar names (especially the Music Network) brought back a flood of memories from the youth they accompanied.
Although the rise of the internet in recent years has diminished the influence of broadcast radio compared to the past, the radio experience remains uniquely comforting. You don’t have to expend mental energy curating playlists; you enjoy ever-changing and rich content, and in the late night, the clear, gentle voices of hosts accompany you through the airwaves. While working late into the night, that feeling of having someone by your side brings genuine solace.
As for why the BCC Music Network and Formosa Network were ordered off the air, clues can be pieced together from news media and circulating rumors. Among them, the four bullet points widely circulated online sum up the narrative, even though they are riddled with inaccuracies:
- Occupying Frequencies: BCC’s frequencies belong to the state. Back then, they claimed they needed them for propaganda warfare against the Communist bandits, and have occupied the frequencies ever since.
- After Occupation: BCC allegedly raked in tens of millions in monthly revenue simply by occupying national frequencies (other meaningless rhetoric is omitted).
- Broken Promises: When Jaw Shaw-kong took over BCC, he promised to return the frequencies, yet continues to occupy them today.
- After Reclaiming: Once the NCC reclaims these frequencies, they will be allocated to Indigenous and Hakka radio stations to protect ethnic minority communication rights.
BUT—and this is life’s most crucial “BUT”!
Has anyone who read and shared these four points ever wondered: “Which frequency spectrum doesn’t belong to the state?”
The original author compiled these four bullet points asserting that the frequencies belong to the state to reinforce the legitimacy of the NCC’s shutdown order, which makes it obvious the author does not come from a science or engineering background (laughs). In particular, the mention that a certain political party supposedly occupied these frequencies for propaganda warfare against the Communists sounds rather comical in hindsight.
My friend, there was a real war going on back then—people actually died.
If anyone doesn’t understand what war truly is, I highly recommend the commemorative film Shooting War [1] (available on YouTube, though since I cannot verify legitimate copyright sources, I won’t link the video stream directly).
Shooting War is a documentary I stumbled across a few days ago while researching photography materials. It compiles extensive raw footage from World War II, allowing us to recognize the cold-blooded reality of warfare through the eyes of photojournalists—one of the most dangerous professions in the world (especially the unreleased footage around the 35:20 mark, which truly grips your heart).
Coincidentally, tensions in Northeast Asia have flared up over recent days with frequent maneuvers among China, the US, Japan, and South Korea. I strongly encourage everyone to make time to watch this documentary!

If we argue that frequencies belong to the state, there are private commercial radio stations right next to the Music Network’s band. Why is BCC the only unlucky one restricted under the noble banner of “the state”? Moreover, reallocating those frequencies to ethnic stations also constitutes utilizing national frequencies! How does that differ in principle from BCC using them in the past? Refusing to let BCC use them and whether they can legitimately be licensed to BCC are two completely different matters!
Furthermore, according to those four claims, simply occupying a channel earns NT$10 million every month? No wonder illicit underground radio stations in central and southern Taiwan peddle unregulated medicines so rampantly—the government’s reluctance to forcefully shut them down is what truly baffles people. This further confirms that the author of those points definitely did not study business.
Since the NCC decided to drastically reshuffle the airwaves without offering leeway that accounts for historical evolution, the action inevitably feels overly harsh.
As for the 10-year span from being told to vacate in 2007 to finally being forcefully taken off the air in 2017, both ends happen to coincide with administrations from the Green camp. It is hardly surprising that many on social media view this shutdown as a form of “green terror”! How many still remember that Chen Shui-bian once attempted to forcefully shut down TVBS to suppress the escalation of uncovered corruption scandals?
If the shutdown was based on the premise: “The lease expired, BCC refused to pay renewal fees and attempted to squat on the band, hence being shut down,” I could accept that.
Or, if it was based on: “The NCC offered BCC priority leasing rights, but BCC voluntarily waived them and was taken off the air,” I could accept that too.
Yet today’s reality clearly fits neither scenario, as BCC appears fully capable of paying frequency leasing fees. If the government forcefully prioritized giving the frequencies to other stations, thereby forcing BCC to abandon channels it nurtured for decades, I consider this approach deeply flawed, disregarding the time and resources invested by listeners and broadcasters over generations. I believe multiple reasons exist behind surrendering the frequencies—perhaps BCC believes its holding is lawful and refuses to capitulate to government authority, perhaps reclaiming costs wasn’t viable (wasn’t it supposedly making 10 million a month?), or perhaps it was purely political.
And please don’t tell me handing them over to other ethnic radio stations is purely benevolent. That simply means for however long BCC engaged in lawful administrative litigation, the government neglected those ethnic communities for just as long, revealing that ethnic broadcasting was merely a convenient pretext for shutting BCC down.
In truth, NCC and BCC both operated within legal channels, so the procedural controversy is relatively bounded (though internet netizens often disregard this premise). However, what I care about is whether the NCC could have offered BCC priority leasing, and why couldn’t they grant BCC a little more time? Allowing their DJ roster and long-time loyal listeners to bid a graceful, well-deserved farewell would have been the humane thing to do. For a state agency to sneak in an official decree right after Friday office hours—aren’t they worried about the Ministry of Labor knocking on their door?
Further Reading / Appendix:
[1] IMDb: Shooting War.
Support Independent Perspectives & In-Depth Insights
Every thoughtful analysis and candid critique comes from our dedication to truth and quality. We choose not to follow sensational algorithms or clickbait headlines.
Sustaining independent research requires reader support. Make a one-time or monthly contribution, securely processed by Google.
Payments secured by Google · Manage or cancel anytime in your Google Account




Comments