Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) “social enterprise legislator” Karen Yu recently planned to rally party legislators to amend the Government Procurement Act, making an enterprise’s “social impact” a key indicator for winning government tenders (Legislative Yuan Bill Documents, Yuan General No. 1650, Member Proposal No. 20534).

Yet within Taiwan alone, quite a few students receiving low-income financial aid are actually children of wealthy families. I cannot help but wonder whether Legislator Yu genuinely intends to anchor a critical government procurement metric on a superficial facade like “social impact”—which, in Chinese societies, often invites deeper cronyism and easier exploitation of loopholes.

When discussing the most prominent fair-trade platform domestically, many immediately think of Okogreen Co., Ltd. Its founder is none other than Karen Yu herself. This has long been public knowledge, and numerous people have raised questions about it. For example, back in March of this year, when Okogreen won a ten-million-dollar government tender, Li Ming-hsien, Deputy Director of the KMT Culture and Communications Committee, cited Article 9 of the Act on Recusal of Public Servants Due to Conflicts of Interest: “Public servants or their related parties shall not engage in transactions such as sales, leases, or contracting with the agency in which the public servant serves or agencies under its supervision.” He argued that since Yu had repeatedly questioned the Ministry of Economic Affairs as a legislator, could her husband not be considered a “related party”? Did she not need to comply with conflict-of-interest recusal laws? Should Okogreen Co., Ltd. be exempt from recusing itself when bidding on government tenders?

Therefore, when Yu proposed in this bill that “social impact” should serve as a pivotal metric for government bids, one cannot help but wonder whether this is tied to the “ShoJio Charity Platform,” a collaboration between the Cathay Life Charity Foundation and Okogreen. The platform advertises rallying numerous social enterprises and non-profit partners to promote ideas of fairness and justice, and to foster sustainable businesses committed to social responsibility. Between the lines, it practically screams, "**Hey, look at my social impact!**" Looking at it from another angle, could joining such a platform become one of the factors defining qualifying “social impact”?

Wouldn’t that turn someone into both the player and the referee? Where is the fairness for the industry? Granted, that assumes actual entanglement after the bill passes.

Taking a step back, who is supposed to certify how much social impact an enterprise actually possesses? Who determines the scoring weight for each factor? Might this create another superficial farce similar to how younger generations rush to join volunteer work merely to rack up points for school admissions, while actually causing endless trouble for non-profit organizations?

For example, when building infrastructure, one could probably build far more bridges in Pingtung than pave roads in Taipei, and do so much more cheaply! Where, then, lies the fairness of so-called “social impact”?

I do not fear falling behind in technical capability; what I fear is that the personal preferences of a few legislators will arbitrarily raise barriers to entry.

Even setting aside the relationship between Yu and Okogreen, and granting that the “most advantageous tender” mechanism in procurement law may indeed have flaws, why is it that the procurement amendment being pushed by the DPP focuses neither on engineering construction quality nor on professional technical expertise, nor even on direct evaluations of project vision, but instead takes a bizarre leap directly to “social impact”?

In Yu’s legislative proposal, social impact is directly defined by factors such as “assisting disadvantaged groups,” “local community development,” and “environmental ecological conservation.” But what do these factors really have to do with engineering quality? At least for those of us with engineering backgrounds, we care about tangible performance and industrial technological advancement. As for “social impact,” that sounds more like something humanities graduates indulge in for poetic, hipster aesthetics.

Furthermore, assisting disadvantaged groups, developing local communities, and preserving ecological environments—which of these does not require substantial financial capital and extensive connections? Wouldn’t this tilt the playing field toward wealthy conglomerates, giving them even more leverage over budding startups to capture government procurement contracts?

The law should be amended, but making it even more bizarre—is that really a good idea?

Those sweating and bleeding on the front lines are in engineering, yet today the judges determining whether engineers qualify come from humanities? In the past, whoever had the deepest pockets to outlast others won the bid; now, instead of figuring out who is best qualified to deliver the work, the system asks who is best at buttering up local communities and playing politics. It is utterly absurd.

You set out to fix the flaws of the lowest-bid system, only to introduce an even more unfair “social impact” regime. Legislators truly leave one baffled!

✦ Independent Journalism · Reader Support ✦

Support Independent Perspectives & In-Depth Insights

Every thoughtful analysis and candid critique comes from our dedication to truth and quality. We choose not to follow sensational algorithms or clickbait headlines.

Sustaining independent research requires reader support. Make a one-time or monthly contribution, securely processed by Google.

Payments secured by Google · Manage or cancel anytime in your Google Account